Across the Aisle: A Brief Look at the Criminal Side of California DUI Law

courthouseAs a DUI injury law firm in Sonoma County, we believe our obligation to represent our clients includes ensuring they understand the legal process.  One of the first things we explain about California DUI injury law is something anyone involved in a legal dispute should know — there are separate legal systems for criminal and civil matters.  Injured parties can file (and win!) civil claims whether or not a criminal charge is filed based on the underlying incident.  Despite the separation, we believe it is helpful for those injured by a drunk driver to understand a bit about criminal DUI charges in California.

The Underlying Laws Against Drinking and Driving

California law contains two broad prohibitions against drunk driving, Vehicle Code 23152(a) and (b).  Section (a) is more general and makes it illegal to drive while under the influence of alcohol.  Section (b) is more specific and prohibits anyone with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.08 or higher from driving in the state.  Notably, this means a person can actually be charged with drunk driving even if their blood alcohol level is below the so-called “legal limit.”  Police often charge drunk drivers with both offenses.  Ultimately, defendants can be convicted of both offenses but they can only receive a punishment for one.

When a DUI results in injury, the charges shift to V.C. 23153(a) and (b).

Types of DUIs

There are several types (or levels) of DUI in California with varying degrees of potential punishments.  The levels are distinguished by several factors including whether there was an accident and/or injury and whether the driver has prior DUI convictions.  Some of the most common types of DUIs include:

  • Misdemeanor DUI, First Offense – This applies to the first-time offender, particularly the driver who is pulled over for a DUI without an accident or injury occurring. Penalties include a fine of $390 to $1,000 (plus costs), jail time of 48 hours to 6 months, and a license suspension of at least 6 months (including 5 months of a restricted license for driving to/from work).
  • Misdemeanor DUI, Second and Subsequent Offenses – Each time a driver is convicted of DUI, the penalties climb.
  • Felony DUI Causing Severe Injury – When a driver seriously injures another person, the charge is often elevated to a felony. Punishment can include 16 months to ten years in state prison and fines up to $5,000.  Felony DUI typically results in a one year revocation of all driving privileges and three years of a restricted work license.
  • Vehicular Manslaughter – When a driver under the influence of alcohol causes the death of another, the resulting charge is often vehicular manslaughter (Penal Code 191.5).   The precise charge depends on whether the driver acted with ordinary negligence (191.5(b), a “wobbler” that can be a misdemeanor or a felony) or gross negligence (191.5(a), a felony).  Penalties include prison terms of up to ten years and fines up to $10,000.

An additional note about Ignition Interlock Devices  (“IIDs”) – IIDs are breathalyzers that attach to a car’s ignition.  They require an alcohol-free breath sample to start the vehicle and the driver must periodically re-test while driving.  Currently, a pilot program requires that anyone convicted of a DUI, even first-time offenders, in Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento, and Tulare Counties install an IID on all vehicles they own or operate for a period ranging from five months to four years.  This is expected to eventually be expanded to the entire state, although judges in other counties have the option of adding an IID requirement to any DUI sentence and certain higher DUI offenses include mandatory IIDs statewide.

Our Civil DUI Injury Practice

It is worth reiterating – If you are injured or lose a loved one because of a drunk driver, you may have a civil claim regardless of whether the driver is charged with a crime.  Call our drunk driving law firm in Santa Rosa, Sacramento, or San Francisco toll-free at (800) 427-7020.

See Related Blog Posts:

Repeat Drunk Drivers: A Look at the Problem of DUI Recidivism

The Impact of Alcohol: Santa Rosa Injury Lawyer Examines the True Meaning of BAC

(Image by Robert Linder)

Contact Information